Joe Rogan Inspired Pizza: Anchovies, Pineapple, and the Spirit of Innovation

Joe Rogan Inspired Pizza: Anchovies, Pineapple, and the Spirit of Innovation

Today, I'm bringing you another one of my unique pizza recipes – and a story along with it. This is about how a casual podcast listen turned into a culinary quest, all within the cozy confines of my kitchen.

The Spark of Inspiration

Let me set the scene: I'm chilling, with Joe Rogan's podcast playing in the background - a usual slice of my day. This time, he has Elon Musk, the visionary of modern tech, electric cars, spaceships, underground tunnel transportation,  come on as a guest, and things take an unexpected turn. They’re unpacking life's big questions when Joe shares his love for a unique pizza topping combo: double anchovies and double pineapple. 

The mix of intense saltiness with a sweet kick caught Elon's interest. In a turn that shows just how spontaneous life can be, they decide to place an order right then and there. And it’s not just any pizza they’re after but an extra-large one, boldly covered with the two probably most polarizing pizza toppings.   

The moment was so surreal, it made its way to TikTok - check out their encounter and witness the pizza in all its glory there! At first, I chuckled at the audacity. But then I thought, "Hey, if it's good enough for two geniuses, it's good enough for my Baking Steel!" So, in a spark of inspiration fueled by Joe and Elon, I decided to recreate this controversial masterpiece. 

The Adventure Begins

Armed with my Baking Steel Original and a big appetite, I went to create my own version of this pizza. I fired up my home oven - the ultimate pizza-making arena - and got down to business. Let me walk you through the magic, step by step: 

Step 1: The Dough

I started with our 72 Hour Dough, after i ball it up i let it rest for 3 hours at room temperature. A pizza's soul lies in its base, after all. I am not messing around, i think our 72 hour dough recipe is as good as it gets.  

Step 2: The Toppings

Then came the stars of the show - anchovies and pineapple. The anchovies, salty and briny, paired with the sweet, tart pineapple created a contrasting flavor profile that could only be described as daringly cool and tasty.

After the dough is stretched, add about 2 tbsp of crushed tomatoes and distribute evenly,  Next add your cheese, we used low moisture mozzarella and fresh mozzarella.  

Step 3: The Bake

With my Baking Steel Original inside, i crank my oven to 500 F for an hour before i launch.  I want all that heat to absorb inside my Steel, so when this pizza hits that scorching hot Steel, magic will be made.

The Moment of Truth

As I took that first bite, the flavors danced a tango on my taste buds. The savory fish, the bursts of pineapple, the chewy crust - it was a harmony of tastes too bold to ignore. And just like that, a homemade pineapple and anchovy pizza inspired by Joe Rogan’s podcast was born in my kitchen.  So, what’s my verdict? After a slice (or three), I'm convinced: Pineapple and anchovy pizza deserves a spot on your plate. It’s a yes from me! 

Why This Pizza Is More Than Just a Meal

To be honest with you, this wasn't just about making pineapple and anchovy pizza. It was about the thrill of creation, the joy of experimentation. It was my way of enjoying the simple pleasures that we sometimes overlook. I believe that every slice tells a story, and this one was about curiosity, inspiration, and the courage to try something new - a unique pizza recipe cooked to perfection on a Baking Steel. 

Share Your Own Pizza Tales!

Now, it's your turn. I've shared my story, and I’d love to hear yours. What's the wackiest homemade pizza you've ever made? Did a podcast or show ever inspire you to cook something unique? Drop your stories below, and let's celebrate the wide (and sometimes wild) world of pizza together.  Keep baking, keep experimenting, and who knows? Maybe your next pizza will also be inspired by the unexpected. 

Until the next slice,


Get your first Baking Steel

Baking Steels and Accessories

Shop our complete collection of carefully crafted Baking Steels and other baking and pizza making accessories.

Shop Now


Here's the secret sauce. Literally.

View Collection

Cooking Classes

For all the aspiring master chefs out there, we've got you covered.

Learn More