Puffy pizza on a baking steel....

24 Hour Puffy Pizza Dough Recipe

Jul 10, 2023

Puffy Pizza (No-Scale Recipe)

This one’s for the puffy-pizza people. Big bubbles, tall crust, minimal stretching and no digital scale. Just cups, teaspoons, and a little patience.

We build puff by not stretching much, letting the dough ferment 12–24 hours, and baking hot on a Baking Steel. It won’t be lab-precision but it will be really, really good.

Caution: this recipe isn’t designed to double or triple. Keep the measures as written and make those 2 cups of flour a little “big.”

Watch how we make this Puffy Pizza step by step. Simple ingredients, no scale required—just cups, spoons, and a hot oven with a Baking Steel.

Jump to recipe ↓

Why This Makes Pizza Puffy

  • Minimal stretch: preserves gas so the rim inflates in the oven.
  • Slow ferment (12–24h): flavor + extensibility without aggressive handling.
  • High heat on steel: rapid oven spring for tall, airy bubbles.

Recipe: Puffy Pizza (Cups & Teaspoons)

Yield: 2 small pizzas  |  Ferment: 12–24 hours  |  Bake: 500°F + broil on Baking Steel

Ingredients

  • 2 big cups organic bread or all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup water
  • 1 tsp sea salt
  • ¼ tsp active dry yeast
  • Quick drizzle olive oil

Method

  1. Mix: In a bowl, whisk flour + salt. Whisk in yeast. Add all the water and mix with a spatula until hydrated, then knead by hand until it comes together. Clean the bowl.
  2. Oil & rest: Return dough to bowl, drizzle with olive oil and knead 2 minutes to coat. Cover and rest 12–24 hours.
  3. Divide & ball: Split into 2 portions. Flour hands, fold and turn to create a smooth, tense surface. Pinch seam closed. Rest balls 3-4 hours at room temp, covered.
  4. Preheat: With 1 hour left, heat oven to 500°F with your Baking Steel on the top rack (convection if available).
  5. Shape minimal: Keep handling light don’t stretch much. You’re preserving gas for puff.
  6. Bake: Build on a floured/semolina peel. Switch to broil; when the broiler fires, launch onto the hot steel. Bake ~2 minutes, rotate, switch back to 500°F convection, and bake ~2 minutes more or until tall, blistered, and golden.
  7. Finish: Cool briefly, slice, and let the bubbles speak for themselves.

Pro Tips for Maximum Puff

  • Warm room = faster ferment; cool room = slower. Use the full 24 hours if it’s chilly.
  • Resisting stretch? Set the dough down for 60–90 seconds and let gluten relax.
  • Go light on toppings so bubbles don’t collapse.
  • Stretch it out, just not too thin.  We want this dough to spring when it hits that hot Steel...

Ready for those Puffy rims?

Bake on a fully preheated Baking Steel for instant oven spring.

 



The Baking Steel Difference

Baking Steel makes your home oven magical.
Before
After

Pizza Night Kit

Get your pizza night started here. Everything you need except the dough.
Baking Steel Plus 15x20 pizza steel for home ovens
$129.00
The Baking Steel Original
The Baking Steel Original
//bakingsteel.com/cdn/shop/files/Baking_Steel_Original.jpg?v=1756492839
Baking Steel Cleaning Bricks Made of Pumice Stone - Baking Steel ®
$29.00
Baking Steel Cleaning Bricks Made of Pumice Stone
Baking Steel Cleaning Bricks Made of Pumice Stone
//bakingsteel.com/cdn/shop/files/bricks.jpg?v=1751656912
The 14" Pizza Peel – Cherry Wood - Baking Steel ®
$69.00
The 14" Pizza Peel – Cherry Wood
The 14" Pizza Peel – Cherry Wood
//bakingsteel.com/cdn/shop/files/IMG_3558.jpg?v=1751656953
Baking Steel Dough Container – 5L Cold Proofing Box - Baking Steel ®
$39.00
Baking Steel Dough Container – 5L Cold Proofing Box
Baking Steel Dough Container – 5L Cold Proofing Box
//bakingsteel.com/cdn/shop/files/IMG_3581.jpg?v=1751656903
Sold Out
Baking Steel Pizza Rocker 12" Blade with Walnut Handles - Baking Steel ®
$69.00
Baking Steel Pizza Rocker 12" Blade with Walnut Handles
Baking Steel Pizza Rocker 12" Blade with Walnut Handles
//bakingsteel.com/cdn/shop/files/IMG_3593.jpg?v=1751656854
Bundle contentsAdd 2 items to get a discount